DC Super Hero Girls: At Metropolis High | Review
DC Super Hero Girls: At Metropolis High
Written by Amy Wolfram, art by Yancey Labat
DC Comics, $9.99
As noted at the end of the DC Super Hero Girls: Spaced Out review, DC Super Hero Girls: At Metropolis High is the first of a new run of the series that changes the concept, characters, and look to match the TV cartoon.
One of the key differences in this second phase of DC Super Hero Girls is that it’s much more conventional in its approach. Half the characters — including Catwoman, Harley Quinn, Star Sapphire, and Poison Ivy — are now back to being villains, and the heroes are attempting to maintain secret identities (which mostly gives them more clothes choices). The stories, themes, and messages are all simpler.
Instead of going to superhero school, the girls are now in a regular school pretending to be normal. Our team of heroes is Supergirl, Batgirl, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Bumblebee (in armor), and Zatanna. In this book, they’re ordered by the principal to join after-school activities, which conflicts with their crime-fighting.
The art is more stylized, in keeping with the exaggerated look of the TV cartoon, but it’s also more static. There’s no sense of flow between these comic panels. Each seems like a frozen moment, and the story jumps from one to another. The best comics, in contrast, create the sense that there is movement happening between the moments we see. Instead, here, it’s like flipping though a stack of photos, where the characters are posing for us in each panel.
I miss the sense of a full DC universe that Fontana’s stories had. The supporting characters here are generic students, just fodder for the background. I also didn’t find these girls anyone I wanted to spend time with. They were caricatures, given supposedly identifiable motives and interests, but it all falls flat. Only Wonder Woman, with an elaborate, archaic way of speaking, has a unique character voice.
As an historical note, these DC Super Hero Girls collections, At Metropolis High and Spaced Out, were the only two published under the short-lived DC Zoom imprint, aimed at middle-grade readers. DC Super Hero Girls: The Search for Atlantis was supposed to be part of the imprint as well, but it was released in 2018 without the branding, when the line’s launch was delayed.
Filed under: All Ages, Graphic Novels, Reviews
Johanna Draper Carlson has been reviewing comics for over 20 years. She manages ComicsWorthReading.com, the longest-running independent review site online that covers all genres of comic books, graphic novels, and manga. She has an MA in popular culture, studying online fandom, and was previously, among many other things, webmaster for DC Comics. She lives in Madison, Wisconsin.
SLJ Blog Network
The 2023 CYBILS Awards Wants YOU!
Review of the Day: Papá’s Magical Water-Jug Clock by Jesús Trejo, ill. Eliza Kinkz
Squire & Knight | Review
Why Sad Books are Vital in Kidlit, a guest post by Cassandra Newbould
The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving