SUBSCRIBE
SUBSCRIBE
SLJ Blog Network +
  • 100 Scope Notes
  • A Fuse #8 Production
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • Heavy Medal: A Mock Newbery Blog
  • Teen Librarian Toolbox
  • The Classroom Bookshelf
  • The Yarn
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About/Contact
  • Previews
  • Reviews
  • Manga
  • All Ages
  • Young Adult
  • Interviews
  • News

March 14, 2010 by Katherine Dacey

Review: A Study in Scarlet

March 14, 2010 by Katherine Dacey   Leave a Comment

In 1887, twenty-seven-year-old doctor Arthur Conan Doyle published his first novel. Called A Study in Scarlet, the ninety-five page work featured a "consulting detective" who solved cases using a mixture of science and shrewd observation. The novel was, by most measures, a flop. Doyle persisted, however, reviving the character in 1890 for The Sign of the Four, and in 1891 for "A Scandal in Bohemia,"  "The Red-Headed League," and "A Case of Identity." It was these short stories that proved enormously popular with the reading public, rescuing Sherlock Holmes from obscurity and transforming him into one of England’s most famous literary creations.

A Study in Scarlet: A Sherlock Holmes Graphic Novel
Adapted from the original novel by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle by I.N.J. Culbard (Art) and Ian Edginton (Script)
Ages 12 and up
2010, Self-Made Hero, ISBN: 978-1-4027-7082-1
130 pp., $14.95

SCROLL TO KEEP READING THIS POST

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Reading A Study in Scarlet, it’s easy to see why Doyle’s freshman effort made little impression on the public. The story is oddly constructed, with a lengthy flashback in which the villain — captured by Holmes midway through the book — explains why he sought revenge on his victims. Odder still, that flashback takes place not in England but in Utah, where Brigham Young’s followers were waging guerilla war against the US government. Doyle was obviously fascinated by period headlines describing Mormonism, but his attempt to tart up the story with sensational details — polygamy, kidnapping — falls flat, especially when contrasted with the more engaging narrative describing how Watson came to live and work with Holmes.

Given the source material’s flaws, Ian Edginton and I.N.J. Culbard have fashioned a silk purse from a sow’s ear with their graphic adaptation of A Study in Scarlet. Their version is more judiciously paced and entertaining than Doyle’s, even while remaining faithful to the source. Edginton preserves as much as the original text as possible while breaking up the narration into digestible chunks — no mean feat, given just how many passages consist of characters telling long, digressive stories. More importantly, Edginton stays close to Doyle’s conception of who Holmes and Watson are, rather than allowing a century of stage plays, movies, and unauthorized sequels to influence the characterizations. (In other words, no one utters "Elementary, my dear Watson!" or swans around London in a fancy cape and hat.)

Culbard’s visuals bring a vigorous, masculine energy to Doyle’s story. As Culbard portrays him, Holmes is a tall, strapping man with a granite jaw and aquiline nose, the sort of person with the strength to subdue a suspect or pursue a lead across London. Watson, on the other hand, has a haunted appearance with deep circles under his eyes — a subtle touch that reflects his traumatic experiences in the Second Anglo-Afghan War (1878-80). Culbard does a similarly fine job of bringing London to life through an imaginative use of color, light, and pattern; he captures the smoky grey of English fog and the warm, orange light of oil lamps, the dark, soot-covered exteriors of London’s brick row houses and the intricately patterned wallpapers that line their interiors, suggesting, in the process, just how dark and claustrophobic Victorian living quarters could be.

Tweens and teens whose only knowledge of Sherlock Holmes come from other media will find this skillful adaptation a great introduction to Doyle’s work, while long-time fans will enjoy seeing how Culbard and Edginton stage Holmes and Watson’s first meeting. Age-wise, the vocabulary and subject-matter are appropriate for readers twelve and up, though precocious Holmes fans will find A Study in Scarlet within their reach. One final note: sensitive readers may object to a passage in which Holmes conducts an experiment on a dog (pp. 76-78). Edginton and Culbard stage the scene quickly and tastefully, but it’s worth noting before recommending the book to an animal-loving mystery buff. That minor caveat aside, A Study in Scarlet makes a solid addition to a middle or high school library.

Review copy provided by Self-Made Hero.

Filed under: Reviews, Uncategorized

SHARE:

Read or Leave Comments

About Katherine Dacey

Katherine Dacey has been reviewing comics since 2006. From 2007 to 2008, she was the Senior Manga Editor at PopCultureShock, a site covering all aspects of the entertainment industry from comics to video games. In 2009, she launched The Manga Critic, where she focuses primarily on Japanese comics and novels in translation. Katherine lives and works in the Greater Boston area, and is a musicologist by training.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

October 2022

Review: Parachute Kids

by Katherine Dacey

July 2011

Review: Drawing From Memory

by Katherine Dacey

May 2011

Review: The Zabime Sisters

by Katherine Dacey

May 2011

First Second Reviews

by Katherine Dacey

March 2011

Review: Skullkickers, vol 1

by Katherine Dacey

ADVERTISEMENT

SLJ Blog Network

100 Scope Notes

Sydney Taylor Blog Tour: THE TOWER OF LIFE by Chana Stiefel and Susan Gal

by Travis Jonker

A Fuse #8 Production

“… A relationship of reciprocity with the Earth.” Diana Sudyka Discusses Her New Picture Book, Little Land

by Betsy Bird

Good Comics for Kids

Haley Newsome on Unfamiliar | Interview

by J. Caleb Mozzocco

Heavy Medal

What’s Coming in 2023, A Feedback Poll, and Goodbye for Now…

by Steven Engelfried

Teen Librarian Toolbox

Showing Teens It’s Okay to be Angry, a guest post by Lauren Blackwood

by Amanda MacGregor

The Classroom Bookshelf

The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving

by Erika Thulin Dawes

The Yarn

A Book 25 Years in the Making: Marla Frazee Visits The Yarn

by Travis Jonker

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles on SLJ

First-Person Graphic Memoirs: 17 Recommended Titles

Q&A: Harmony Becker, Creator of "Himawari House"

A Woman’s Place Is in a Graphic Novel: Outstanding Works for Young Readers Center Women in History

2 Graphic Novels About Making Friends in Middle School

'Himawari House' Wins 2022 Kirkus Prize for Young Readers' Literature

Commenting for all posts is disabled after 30 days.

ADVERTISEMENT

Archives

Follow This Blog

Enter your email address below to receive notifications of new blog posts by email.

This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

This coverage is free for all visitors. Your support makes this possible.

Primary Sidebar

  • News & Features
  • Reviews+
  • Technology
  • School Libraries
  • Public Libraries
  • Age Level
  • Ideas
  • Blogs
  • Classroom
  • Diversity
  • People
  • Job Zone

Reviews+

  • Book Lists
  • Best Books
  • Media
  • Reference
  • Series Made Simple
  • Tech
  • Review for SLJ
  • Review Submissions

SLJ Blog Network

  • 100 Scope Notes
  • A Fuse #8 Production
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • Heavy Medal
  • Neverending Search
  • Teen Librarian Toolbox
  • The Classroom Bookshelf
  • The Yarn

Resources

  • 2022 Youth Media Awards
  • The Newbery at 100: SLJ Celebrates the 100th Anniversary of the Award
  • Special Report | School Libraries 2021
  • Summer Reading 2021
  • Series Made Simple Spring 2021
  • SLJ Diverse Books Survey
  • Summer Programming Survey
  • Research
  • White Papers / Case Studies
  • School Librarian of the Year
  • Mathical Book Prize Collection Development Awards
  • Librarian/Teacher Collaboration Award

Events & PD

  • In-Person Events
  • Online Courses
  • Virtual Events
  • Webcasts
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Media Inquiries
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • Content Submissions
  • Data Privacy
  • Terms of Use
  • Terms of Sale
  • FAQs
  • Diversity Policy
  • Careers at MSI


COPYRIGHT © 2023


COPYRIGHT © 2023