Women’s History Month: Spotlight on manga
Love Roma (Minoru Toyoda, Del Rey Manga)
KATHERINE DACEY’S PICKS
Crimson Hero (Mitsuba Takanashi, VIZ)
Kaze Hikaru (Taeko Watanabe, VIZ)
The Legend of Chun Hyang (CLAMP, Tokyopop)
Two Flowers for the Dragon (Nari Kusikawa, CMX)
ESTHER KELLER’S PICKS
Translucent (Kasuhiro Okamoto, Dark Horse)
Train + Train (Hideyuki Kurata, Go!Comi)
I guess technically this could have gone on the Western list, but I think of this as a manga. People do lots of crazy things for love, but Miki withstands a lot for the guy she loves. And she keeps true to herself at the same time.
Emma (Kaoru Mori, CMX)
Naruto (Masashi Kishimoto, VIZ)
Bleach (Tite Kubo, VIZ)
Love*Com (Aya Nakahara, VIZ)
Honey Hunt (Miki Aihara, VIZ)
Filed under: Uncategorized
About Katherine Dacey
Katherine Dacey has been reviewing comics since 2006. From 2007 to 2008, she was the Senior Manga Editor at PopCultureShock, a site covering all aspects of the entertainment industry from comics to video games. In 2009, she launched The Manga Critic, where she focuses primarily on Japanese comics and novels in translation. Katherine lives and works in the Greater Boston area, and is a musicologist by training.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
One Star Review, Guess Who? (#212)
31 Days, 31 Lists: 2024 Picture Book Reprints
The Seven Bills That Will Safeguard the Future of School Librarianship
Take Five: Wintery Middle Grade Fiction
ADVERTISEMENT
Sesho says
I completely agree with Naruto, especially in terms of Sakura’s character. I’m glad Kishimoto matured her from a little girl that worried about her big forehead and fighting over Sasuke to probably the most powerful and skillful ninja on Naruto’s team. Besides that, she also serves as the medic, which makes her doubly important. What about Ghost in the Shell? Major Motoko Kusanagi is one of the strongest characters, male or female, in all of anime or manga. And let’s not forget xxxHolic. Would the CLAMP universe even function without Yuko running time and space? Eden is overlooked a lot, and even though it focuses on some of the more ”
Sesho says
I completely agree with Naruto, especially in terms of Sakura’s character. I’m glad Kishimoto matured her from a little girl that worried about her big forehead and fighting over Sasuke to probably the most powerful and skillful ninja on Naruto’s team. Besides that, she also serves as the medic, which makes her doubly important. What about Ghost in the Shell? Major Motoko Kusanagi is one of the strongest characters, male or female, in all of anime or manga. And let’s not forget xxxHolic. Would the CLAMP universe even function without Yuko running time and space? Eden is overlooked a lot, and even though it focuses on some of the more ”
Heather says
I disagree about Naruto and Bleach.
Heather says
wow, it let me post finally. Sadly what ever configuation you guys are using does not work well. 6 times I tried to post. The system hates my comments or my titles. Shonen titles – Claymore, Silent Mobius, Maison Ikkoku and Club 9.
Heather says
I would like to think others are having the same problem posting as me. One last time. Gakuen Alice, Azumanga Daioh, Cardcaptor Sakura and Hollow Fields. These titles were at the bottom of my list. I had twelve others I could not list.
Kittyan says
I haven’t read many of these mangas, but I have to disagree with Bleach. The girls don’t do nearly as much as the guys nor do they kick much ass.
The problem with identifying strong females in manga today is that truly strong females are VERY RARE. People tend to think that if the female sort of does something and contributes a little, it means shes strong. A truly strong female would be one who could do as much as the males in the manga and kick just as much butt, and is not constantly needing rescue or protection from the men. The only ”
Kittyan says
The only “strong” females that don’t need male protection in manga that I’ve read so far is Claymore… despite the outfits and the almost S&M themes in it.
I think I’ll try out Pumpkin Scissors from your list though. 🙂
Katherine Dacey says
Ladies, I’m sorry you had so much difficulty posting! The spam filter here at the School Library Journal is robust (to say the least) and quick to reject anything it thinks is advertising. I’ve had the same experience, so I understand your frustration and appreciate your perseverance. One quick note: since the focus of our blog is on comics for kids and teens, a few of the titles you suggest (e.g. <
Katherine Dacey says
One quick note: since the focus of our blog is on comics for kids and teens, a few of the titles you suggest (e.g. Eden: It’s An Endless World) didn’t make the cut, as they’re more appropriate for older teens and adults. If we weren’t restricted, I’d have added Club 9 and Lady Snowblood to my list of manga with strong female characters.
Heather says
Glad to see I was not the only one having trouble posting, but it is extremely frustrating. Here are some others I would recommend Swan, GALS and Nodame Cantibile.
Heather says
Hurray, I was able to reply again. It seems Arina Tamemura’s Fullmoon is the main culprit from my list.
Heather says
Hurray, I was able to reply again. It seems Arina Tamemura’s Fullmoon is the main culprit from my list.
taisa08 says
I’m glad to see Kaze Hikaru mentioned. It’s a great series featuring a very admirable female lead, but I feel like it doesn’t receive all the notice it should. Hooray for Sei!